NCookieAA Semifinals: Round 2

July 25, 2014

Sugar wafers
Teddy Grahams
Barnum's animal crackers
Chips Ahoy, original
Chips Ahoy, chewy
Girl Scout Samoas

The Brothers Chips will fight it out with each other and with Samoas for the top spot in this flight. I'm thrilled the wonderfully cardboard-y sugar wafers made it this far and they'll definitely get my vote, but I don't honestly believe that they, nor anyone else, really have much of a chance here. --Stephanie V.W. Lucianovic

* * * *

A couple of these semifinalists surprised me by getting out of the first round, so this one's probably Chips Ahoy Red's to lose, barring a Cinderella rally from the Samoae. I'll be voting animal crackers, but has anyone else noticed how nutty expensive the Barnum's have gotten for a small box? The carry "strap" is cute, but it's not made out of a tennis bracelet. Total brand tax, IMO. -- Sarah D. Bunting

VOTE!